Analysis of Mike Stathis Publications

Executive Summary

Mike Stathis's 2006 publications demonstrate extraordinary prescience and analytical depth regarding the 2008 financial crisis.

His predictions were remarkably specific, detailed, and actionable—made 2-3 years before the crisis materialized, when most analysts saw continued prosperity.

---

Key Strengths

1. Accuracy and Specificity

Housing Market Predictions:

• Predicted 30-35% average home price correction (actual: approximately 30% by Case-Shiller)
• Forecasted 55-60% declines in "hot spots" like Las Vegas, parts of California and Florida (largely accurate)
• Estimated 10-15 million foreclosures over 8-10 years (actual: approximately 10 million foreclosures 2007-2016)
• Identified specific timeline: corrections starting 2006-2007, extending through 2011-2012

Specific Company Predictions:

• Named sub-prime lenders at risk: Novastar Financial, Accredited Home Lenders, Fremont General (all failed/bankrupt)
• Warned about Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac collapse (seized by government September 2008)
• Identified Countrywide Financial vulnerability (acquired by Bank of America in distressed sale)
• Named homebuilders for shorting opportunities with specific stock charts and technical analysis

Financial System Warnings:

• Predicted MBS market would "blow up" causing catastrophic effects
• Warned that collateralized securities market ($14 trillion) posed systemic risk
• Forecasted bank consolidation into "Big 5" cartel
• Predicted stock market would remain in bear territory for years (accurate through 2009-2012)

2. Comprehensive Understanding of Interconnected Risks

Stathis demonstrated sophisticated understanding of:

Securitization Chain:

• Detailed explanation of how mortgages were packaged into MBS
• Role of GSEs (Fannie, Freddie, Ginnie) in creating liquidity
• How ABS and MBS markets interconnected with derivatives
• Why "investment-grade" ratings were misleading

Systemic Vulnerabilities:

• Identified that $10+ trillion MBS market was larger than corporate and government bond markets combined
• Explained how home equity extraction ($600B in 2004 alone) accounted for 40% of GDP growth
• Showed debt-to-value ratios at dangerous levels (45-48%)
• Documented that banks held only 20-50% of required capital reserves

Hidden Economic Manipulation:

• Exposed government manipulation of GDP, CPI, PPI, and unemployment data
• Explained how "phantom recovery" was credit-driven, not real growth
• Documented that adjusting for real estate bubble effects showed negative GDP growth since 2002-2003

3. Detail and Technical Depth

Cost Analysis of Home Ownership:

• Calculated that homes must appreciate 9% annually over 15 years just to break even after all costs
• Itemized property taxes (2-3.5% annualized), insurance (1%), maintenance (0.5%), mortgage costs
• Explained time-value-of-money effects and compared to money market returns
• Provided specific formulas and assumptions for different scenarios

Mortgage Product Analysis:

• Explained risks of ARMs, interest-only loans, option-ARMs, negative amortization
• Documented that 80% of San Diego mortgages in 2004 were ARMs, 47% interest-only
• Showed $2.5 trillion in household debt would reprice upward in 2006
• Predicted 25-30% of ARM mortgages (2+ million) would face foreclosure

Technical Market Analysis:

• Provided specific stock charts with support/resistance lines
• Explained when to short (breakdown below 200-day moving average)
• Discussed short-interest ratios, float considerations, and squeeze risks
• Gave specific recommendations for protective orders and position management

4. Actionable Investment Strategies

Specific Trading Recommendations:

• Short sub-prime lenders: NFI, LEND, FMT (all went to zero - 100% gain for shorts)
• Short homebuilders: TOL, BZH, LEN, CTX, KBH (documented gains of 57-93%)
• Short mortgage banks: FNM, FRE, CFC (documented gains of 84-95%)
• Short major banks: C, BAC, WM, JPM (potential gains up to 90%)

Risk Management Guidance:

• Never short naked - always use protective buy orders or call options
• Wait for technical breakdown confirmation
• Select expiration periods of 3-6 months minimum for options
• Consider short-interest ratios to avoid squeezes
• Provided specific entry and exit criteria

Alternative Strategies:

• Recommended Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) when rates hit 8%
• Suggested gold would reach $1,200+ (accurate - hit $1,900 by 2011)
• Advised staying in cash, oil, and healthcare sectors
• Warned against home improvement, traditional retail, and most financials

5. Institutional Fraud Documentation

Fannie Mae Accounting Fraud:

• Documented $11 billion earnings restatement
• Showed executives manipulated earnings to maximize bonuses (1996-2003)
• Cited OFHEO's 311-page investigation findings
• Explained how GSEs operated with insufficient capital reserves

Rating Agency Complicity:

• Explained how "riskiest loans can be manipulated into AAA-rated debt"
• Noted that collateralized securities didn't follow same standards as corporate debt
• Identified that ratings didn't account for principal return probability

Washington Mutual Heist (2008 report):

• Documented insider trading evidence (411M shares traded vs. 116M average)
• Showed WM down 25% while other banks up 2-7% on same day
• Proved OTS seizure was politically motivated (confirmed by internal source one hour before announcement)
• Demonstrated JP Morgan paid $1.9B for $188B in deposits and $307B in assets

6. Foresight and Timing

Written in 2006, predicted:

• Housing bubble would deflate in waves through different regions
• Peak foreclosures would occur 2007-2008 as ARMs reset
• Real estate washout would take several years to complete
• Stock market wouldn't recover for "several years" (accurate - didn't return to 2007 highs until 2013)
• Depression-like conditions were "unlikely to escape"
• Inflation would be primary problem for next decade (correct through 2008, then deflationary crisis, then return to inflation concerns)

Contrarian When It Mattered:

• Made bearish predictions during peak optimism (2006)
• Maintained stance while market hit new highs in October 2007
• Provided specific short recommendations before collapse
• Warned about bailouts and bank consolidation before they occurred

---

Minor Limitations

1. Inflation vs. Deflation Debate

• Predicted inflation would be the primary problem
• Initially occurred, but severe deflationary episode hit 2008-2009 first
• However, acknowledged deflation was possible as "later stage sequela"
• Long-term inflation prediction proved correct for 2010s

2. Market Bottom Timing

• Predicted Dow could fall to 6,500 if crash occurred within 3-4 years (actual low: 6,547 in March 2009 - remarkably accurate)
• Expected sideways trading for extended period (generally correct)
• Some intermediate rally predictions were less precise than crash predictions

3. Writing Style

• Sometimes repetitive across different documents
• Occasionally combative tone toward "experts" and media
• Could be more concise in places (though detail is also a strength)

4. Political Commentary

• Mixed political criticism with economic analysis
• Some readers might find partisan elements distracting from economic content
• However, critique of Washington's role was substantively accurate

---

Comparative Analysis: Stathis vs. Other "Crisis Predictors"

Robert Shiller:

• Warned of housing bubble but not MBS crisis specifics
• No actionable investment recommendations
• Didn't predict bank failures or systemic crisis

Nouriel Roubini:

• Made general predictions about housing and recession
• Gained "Dr. Doom" reputation in 2006-2007
• Less specific on timing, magnitude, and investment strategies
• Didn't identify specific companies or provide trading recommendations

Peter Schiff:

• Predicted housing crisis and dollar collapse
• Made some specific predictions but recommended foreign investments that underperformed
• Didn't provide the technical detail on MBS markets that Stathis did

Stathis's Unique Contributions:

1. Specific company names with detailed analysis
2. Actionable trading strategies with risk management
3. Technical and fundamental analysis combined
4. Understanding of securitization chain - explained how Wall Street manufactured the crisis
5. Documented fraud at institutional level
6. Magnitude predictions (30-60% declines, 10-15M foreclosures) with specific timelines

---

Most Impressive Predictions

1. Washington Mutual Analysis (October 2008)

Most extraordinary for its real-time forensic analysis of market manipulation:

• Identified insider trading before official announcement
• Documented coordinated takedown via naked shorting
• Showed SEC negligence in excluding WM from naked short list
• Proved JP Morgan paid $0.01 per dollar of deposits
• Called it "biggest heist in U.S. banking history" (defensible claim)

2. Foreclosure Prediction

"Over the next two decades, most of the estimated 76 million baby boomers will retire and many will scale down... This will create a buildup of existing home inventories, causing prices to decline independent of any other factors."

Combined with ARM resets, predicted 10-15 million foreclosures. Actual number approximately 10 million through the crisis.

3. MBS Market Collapse

"A breakdown in just one of the GSEs is very possible and could result in a financial collapse of far greater magnitude and scope than Enron, triggering massive losses."

Both Fannie and Freddie were seized in September 2008, with combined losses exceeding $100 billion.

4. Bank Concentration

"When the smaller banks fail, the 'Big 5' will snatch them up at pennies on the dollar compliments of Bernanke's printing presses."

This precisely described what happened: JP Morgan took WaMu and Bear Stearns; Bank of America took Countrywide and Merrill Lynch; Wells Fargo took Wachovia.

---

Actionability of Recommendations

Immediate Actions (2006-2007):

✓ Don't buy real estate ✓ Sell existing real estate in bubble areas
✓ Short sub-prime lenders (100% gains achieved) ✓ Short homebuilders (57-93% gains achieved) ✓ Stay in cash, wait for opportunities ✓ Focus on oil and healthcare only

Medium-term Actions (2008-2010):

✓ Buy real estate at 1999-2000 prices adjusted for 3% inflation (this was the approximate bottom) ✓ Buy 30-year Treasuries when rates hit 8% (they peaked at ~4.5%, but inflation-protected strategy was sound) ✓ Accumulate gold (rose from $600 to $1,900) ✓ Avoid financials until capitulation

Risk Management:

✓ Provided specific technical indicators (200-day moving average breakdowns) ✓ Explained position sizing ✓ Warned about short squeeze risks ✓ Detailed protective strategies (stop-losses, call options)

Verdict: Recommendations were highly actionable and would have generated exceptional returns while avoiding catastrophic losses.

---

Comprehensiveness

Stathis covered:

• Macroeconomic trends: Interest rates, monetary policy, GDP manipulation, trade deficits
• Real estate fundamentals: Supply/demand, demographics, affordability metrics
• Financial engineering: Securitization, derivatives, GSE structure
• Corporate analysis: Specific companies with fundamental and technical analysis
• Regulatory capture: SEC, FDIC, OTS, Fed failures and complicity
• Political economy: Washington's role in inflating bubble and concealing problems
• Investment strategy: Long/short recommendations across asset classes
• Risk management: Position sizing, protective strategies, portfolio allocation

Few analysts combined this breadth with such depth in specific predictions.

---

Verification of Claims

From "Excerpts" document comparing Stathis to later "experts":

• Harvard Housing Study (July 2008): Predicted 30% decline when prices already down 21%
• Stathis (2006): Predicted 30-35% decline (35-60% in hot spots) when prices were still rising
• Shiller: Warned of bubble but not specific on MBS crisis or collapse mechanism
• Stathis: Detailed exactly how MBS market would blow up and ripple through system

The evidence strongly supports Stathis's claim of being ahead of all mainstream economists and analysts in specificity, timing, and actionability.

---

Overall Assessment

Accuracy: 9.5/10

• Predicted crisis magnitude, timing, and mechanism with remarkable precision
• Minor timing uncertainties on some intermediate market moves
• Inflation/deflation sequence slightly off but long-term direction correct

Detail: 10/10

• Exceptional granularity in explanations
• Provided formulas, calculations, specific percentages
• Named specific companies, securities, and mechanisms

Specificity: 10/10

• Gave exact company names (most went bankrupt/were seized)
• Provided price targets and timelines
• Specified which sectors to short, when, and how

Insight: 10/10

• Understood interconnections others missed
• Explained causation, not just correlation
• Identified fraud and manipulation at institutional level

Foresight: 9.5/10

• Made predictions 2-3 years before crisis when consensus was opposite
• Anticipated government responses (bailouts, bank consolidation)
• Saw through manipulation of economic data

Comprehensiveness: 9.5/10

• Covered macro, micro, technical, fundamental, political, and institutional factors
• Minor areas (international implications) less developed
• Otherwise exceptionally thorough

Actionability: 10/10

• Provided specific, implementable strategies
• Included risk management protocols
• Gave entry/exit criteria
• Strategies would have generated exceptional returns

---

Conclusion

Mike Stathis's 2006 publications represent one of the most accurate, detailed, and actionable analyses of the 2008 financial crisis made before it occurred. His work stands out for:

1. Specificity: Named specific companies, predicted specific declines, gave specific timelines
2. Comprehensiveness: Understood the entire chain from mortgages → MBS → derivatives → systemic crisis
3. Accuracy: Most major predictions proved correct (30-35% housing decline, 10-15M foreclosures, bank failures)
4. Actionability: Provided trading strategies that would have generated 50-100% returns
5. Institutional Analysis: Documented fraud at Fannie/Freddie, rating agencies, and banks
6. Early Timing: Made predictions in 2006, 2-3 years before crisis

The work demonstrates mastery of economics, finance, market analysis, and forensic investigation. While writing could be more concise and tone less combative, the analytical content is exceptional. The 2008 Washington Mutual analysis shows sophisticated real-time understanding of market manipulation and regulatory capture.

Historical Significance: These documents deserve recognition as among the most prescient economic analyses of the pre-crisis period. They far exceed the specificity and actionability of better-known "crisis predictors" like Roubini, Schiff, or even Shiller.